Goodreads Was Wrong Book Tag

I was browsing through my blog posts and this tag caught my eye. It was featured on The Bibliophile Thoughts and after reading her answers, I decided “Why not.

I have been using Goodreads to track my books since 2011 (Ok, its been 10 freaking years?!?!?). I do have accounts on other sites (The StoryGraph, Bookhype, and Readerly with The StoryGraph coming in at #2) but Goodreads is my go to.


This tag is originally created by GabsAboutBooks, so make sure to check it out and without further ado let’s get into the tag!


1. WHAT IS THE HIGHEST RATED BOOK THAT YOU GAVE A LOW RATING? (SORT YOUR BOOKS IN GOODREADS BASED ON AVERAGE RATINGS AND FIND THE HIGHEST RATED BOOK YOU GAVE A LOW RATING)

Book Cover
Moon Blood (Book 2) by Carol McKibben

2. WHAT IS THE LOWEST RATED BOOK THAT YOU GAVE A HIGH RATING? (SORT YOUR BOOKS IN GOODREADS BASED ON AVERAGE RATINGS, IN REVERSE ORDER, AND FIND THE LOWEST RATED BOOK YOU GAVE A HIGH RATING)

Book Cover
Thunder Valley by Thomas Kelly

3. WHAT IS THE MOST POPULAR BOOK YOU DISAGREE WITH THE AVERAGE RATING? (SORT YOUR BOOKS IN GOODREADS BASED ON NUMBER OF RATINGS, AND FIND THE FIRST BOOK YOU DISAGREE WITH THE AVERAGE RATING)

Book Cover
The Viscount and the Witch by Michael J. Sullivan

4. WHAT IS THE LEAST POPULAR BOOK YOU DISAGREE WITH THE AVERAGE RATING? (SORT YOUR BOOKS IN GOODREADS BASED ON NUMBER OF RATINGS, IN REVERSE ORDER, AND FIND THE FIRST BOOK YOU DISAGREE WITH THE AVERAGE RATING)

Book Cover
Beautiful Broken Girls by Kim Savage

5. CHOOSE TWO BOOKS THAT HAVE AN AVERAGE RATING OF 3/5 STARS BUT YOU GAVE A HIGHER RATING?

Book Cover
The Swarm by Rob Heinze
Book Cover
Get Some by Daniel Birch

6. CHOOSE TWO BOOKS THAT HAVE AN AVERAGE RATING OF 3/5 STARS BUT YOU GAVE A LOWER RATING

Book Cover
Freak City by Tom Lichtenberg
Book Cover
More than a Slave by Anaelle Gadeyne

7 CHOOSE TWO BOOKS THAT HAVE AN AVERAGE RATING OF 4/5 STARS BUT YOU GAVE A LOWER RATING?

Book Cover
When Angels Fall by H.A. Corby
Book Cover
Darkin: The Prophecy of the Key by Joseph A. Turkot

So, that’s it. If you click on the covers, you can see the star ratings I gave to each book (I am kinda crunched for time right now).

I am supposed to tag people but I am leaving it open. If you want to do this tag, go for it!!

Author: Jolie

I love to read. My favorite genres women's fiction, romance (including erotica), psychological thrillers, fantasy, young adult, steampunk, dystopian, LGBTQIA, and paranormal. I am also a busy mom of 3 kids.

2 thoughts

  1. Oh this is a fun sounding tag! I often very strongly disagree with other people’s opinions on books so I bet I could find some pretty interesting answers for these questions. Sadly, I don’t use Goodreads as much (or as effectively) as I should either. Loved this post!

    1. Thank you!! I went back and forth on doing it (because I have strong opinions too…lol). I’m glad I did it because I was surprised at what I had on my shelf.

Leave a Reply